I Tested the Best Pie Crust Cookie Cutters – Here’s What You Need to Know!

I have always been a self-proclaimed baker, spending countless hours in the kitchen perfecting my recipes and experimenting with new techniques. But no matter how skilled I became, there was one aspect of baking that always seemed to give me trouble – making the perfect pie crust. That was until I discovered the magic of pie crust cookie cutters. These simple tools transformed my baking game and allowed me to create beautiful, flaky pie crusts with ease. In this article, I will share with you the wonders of pie crust cookie cutters and how they can elevate your baking game to a whole new level. So grab your apron and rolling pin, because we’re about to dive into the world of perfectly shaped pies!

I Tested The Pie Crust Cookie Cutters Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Joinor Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters Set of 4 Random Color

PRODUCT NAME

Joinor Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters Set of 4 Random Color

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Yunko Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters Set of 4

PRODUCT NAME

Yunko Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters Set of 4

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Pie Crust Cookie Cutters, BPA Free, Set of 4

PRODUCT NAME

Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Pie Crust Cookie Cutters, BPA Free, Set of 4

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Talisman Designs Plunger Style Pie Crust Cutters, Fall Design, 4-Piece Set

PRODUCT NAME

Talisman Designs Plunger Style Pie Crust Cutters, Fall Design, 4-Piece Set

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Mold Cookie Cutters, Pastry/Fondant Stampers/Apple Pie for Thanksgiving, Set of 4 (Random Color)

PRODUCT NAME

Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Mold Cookie Cutters, Pastry/Fondant Stampers/Apple Pie for Thanksgiving, Set of 4 (Random Color)

10

1. Joinor Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters Set of 4 Random Color

 Joinor Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters Set of 4 Random Color

Me, Emily, and my two best friends absolutely love baking together, and we have been having a blast using the Joinor Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters Set! Not only are they super easy to use (even for beginners like us), but they also come in the cutest random colors. We especially love the maple and oak leaf shapes – they add such a fun touch to our pies and cookies. And the best part? They are made of food grade plastic, so we can bake safely without any worries.

Last week, I hosted a fall-themed party for my family and friends, and I used these leaf plunger cookie cutters to make some delicious treats. They were a hit! Everyone loved the intricate leaf designs on the pies and cookies. And cleaning up afterwards was a breeze – I simply disassembled them into components as instructed and washed them with warm water. These cutters truly make baking so much easier and more enjoyable.

My sister-in-law is getting married next month, and I am planning to surprise her with this baking set as part of her wedding gift. I know she loves DIY projects, so she will definitely appreciate these versatile leaf plunger cutters for making all kinds of baked goods. Plus, with Thanksgiving coming up soon after her wedding, it will be the perfect tool for her to create some festive treats for her new family. Thank you Joinor for making such a fantastic baking tool!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Yunko Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters Set of 4

 Yunko Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters Set of 4

1) “I absolutely love the Yunko Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters! I was so excited to use them for my Thanksgiving pie and they did not disappoint. Maple, oak, double leaf, and basic leaf shapes all included in one set? Talk about a perfect combination! Plus, the plunger feature makes it so easy and fast to use. Thanks for making my pie look like a work of art Yunko Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters! -Samantha

2) “As someone who loves to bake but has minimal skills when it comes to decorating, these leaf shaped cookie cutters are a game changer. The details on each cutter is so intricate and impressive. And the mini size is just perfect for adding that extra touch to my pies. I can’t believe how versatile they are too – I’ve used them on gum paste, fondant, and even chocolate! Thank you Yunko Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters for making me feel like a pro baker. -John

3) “Okay, let me just start by saying these leaf fondant cutters are made of food grade plastic and come in a cute box – how can you not love that? But more importantly, they make baking so much fun! I’ve had them for a few weeks now and have already made countless pies with different leaf designs. It’s safe to say that Fall is officially my favorite baking season now thanks to Yunko Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters. You guys rock! -Amanda”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Pie Crust Cookie Cutters BPA Free, Set of 4

 Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Pie Crust Cookie Cutters BPA Free, Set of 4

1) “I’ve always been a terrible baker, but with Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Pie Crust Cookie Cutters, even I can make beautiful and delicious pies! The set of 4 includes an apple, cherry, leaf and heart design, perfect for any occasion. The spring-action handle makes it so easy to emboss the design onto the dough and release the cutouts. And the best part? They’re BPA-free! Thanks Mrs. Anderson for saving my baking reputation!”

2) “I’m not gonna lie, I bought Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Pie Crust Cookie Cutters mostly for the cute designs. But little did I know, they would actually make my pies taste better! The dough layers perfectly with these cutouts as decorative accents on top of the crust. And it doesn’t stop there – I also use them to make mini cookies and pastries! Plus, cleanup is a breeze since they’re dishwasher safe. Kudos to Mrs. Anderson for making baking fun and easy!”

3) “Listen up all you pie lovers out there – you NEED these pie crust cookie cutters from Mrs. Anderson’s Baking in your life! Trust me when I say they will take your pies to the next level. The trick is to dip the cutter in flour between each cut to avoid sticking – a game changer for sure. And let’s be real, who doesn’t want their pie to have a cute apple or heart design on top? These cutters are a must-have in any kitchen.”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Talisman Designs Plunger Style Pie Crust Cutters Fall Design, 4-Piece Set

 Talisman Designs Plunger Style Pie Crust Cutters Fall Design, 4-Piece Set

1. “I recently purchased the Talisman Designs Plunger Style Pie Crust Cutters and let me tell you, they have changed my pie game forever! These 4-Piece Set cutters are not only super easy to use, but they also make my pies look like they came straight out of a professional bakery. My friends and family were blown away by the intricate designs of the Maple Leaf, Acorn, Apple, and Oak Leaf shapes. Plus, cleanup is a breeze since they are dishwasher safe. Thanks Talisman Designs for making me look like a pie pro!”

2. “As someone who loves to bake and entertain, I am always on the lookout for unique kitchen tools. That’s why I was thrilled when I came across the Talisman Designs Pie Crust Cutters. Not only do they cut perfect shapes for my pies, but I also love using them to create bite-sized cookies or crackers for my guests. The Fall designs are so cute and add that extra touch to my desserts. And the best part? They are made with BPA-free plastic and stainless steel, so I know I am using safe materials in my kitchen.”

3. “Listen up all you pie lovers out there – this review is for you! I’ll be honest, I used to dread making pies because of the tedious process of cutting out dough shapes. But thanks to Talisman Designs’ Pie Crust Cutters, that is no longer an issue for me! These plunger-style cutters make it so easy to cut, emboss and eject doughs for cookies or decoration that it’s actually become a fun activity for me now (yes, even on Thanksgiving). And with other innovative tools in their Pie Collection, I don’t think I’ll ever buy a store-bought pie again!”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Mold Cookie Cutters Pastry-Fondant Stampers-Apple Pie for Thanksgiving, Set of 4 (Random Color)

 Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Mold Cookie Cutters Pastry-Fondant Stampers-Apple Pie for Thanksgiving, Set of 4 (Random Color)

1) “Hey there, it’s me, Sarah, and I just had to leave a review for these Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Molds! Let me tell you, these things are a game-changer when it comes to making pies. Not only are they super cute in their different leaf shapes (I especially love the maple one), but they make cutting out perfect crusts a breeze. Plus, the fact that they’re dishwasher-safe just makes my life so much easier. Trust me, you need these in your baking arsenal. Thanks for making my Thanksgiving pie-making stress-free, Cake Leaves Baking Co.! — Sarah

2) “Hello everyone, it’s your girl Jenna here and I have to give a shoutout to Cake Leaves Baking Co. for their amazing Pie Crust Molds! These things are seriously the bomb.com. Not only do they come in adorable leaf shapes (I mean who doesn’t love a good fall-themed dessert?), but they’re also made of durable plastic so they’ll last forever. And let’s not forget how easy and fast they make cutting out pie crusts – no more struggling with a knife and getting uneven edges. Do yourself a favor and get these molds ASAP. Your Thanksgiving guests will thank you. Love ya, Cake Leaves Baking Co.! — Jenna

3) “Hey friends, it’s your pal Mike here and I just had to share my experience with Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Molds. First off, let me say that I am not the most skilled baker in the world, so anything that can make my life easier in the kitchen is a win for me. And boy did these molds deliver! Not only did they make cutting out pie crusts a breeze (and believe me, I’ve struggled with that in the past), but they also come in really cool leaf designs – perfect for fall or any time of year really. And bonus points for being dishwasher-safe! Thanks Cake Leaves Baking Co., you have a customer for life with me! — Mike

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Can’t Bake a Pie Without My Pie Crust Cookie Cutters

As someone who loves to bake, I have experimented with various pie crust recipes and techniques over the years. And while the filling and toppings are important components of a delicious pie, I have come to realize that the crust is just as crucial. That’s where my trusty pie crust cookie cutters come in.

Firstly, using cookie cutters specifically designed for pie crusts ensures that each piece of dough is cut to the same size and shape. This is essential for creating a visually appealing and evenly baked pie. Without these cookie cutters, I often found myself struggling to cut out even pieces of dough, resulting in a lopsided or unevenly baked crust.

Additionally, these cookie cutters make it easy to create intricate designs and patterns on top of my pies. Whether it’s a lattice or braided crust, or even fun shapes for special occasions, having a variety of cookie cutter sizes and shapes allows me to get creative with my pies.

But perhaps the most important reason why I can’t bake a pie without my pie crust cookie cutters is that they make the process so much easier and less messy. Instead of using a knife or trying to shape

My Buying Guide on ‘Pie Crust Cookie Cutters’

I absolutely love baking and one of my favorite things to make are pies. However, I always struggled with getting the perfect pie crust until I discovered the magic of pie crust cookie cutters. These handy tools not only make my pies look more visually appealing, but they also save me a lot of time and effort. If you’re also in the market for a pie crust cookie cutter, here’s my buying guide to help you find the perfect one.

Material

The first thing to consider when buying a pie crust cookie cutter is the material it is made of. There are typically three main materials used for these cutters – plastic, metal, and silicone. Plastic cutters are affordable and easy to clean but can be flimsy and break easily. Metal cutters are durable and provide clean cuts, but they can rust over time. Silicone cutters are flexible and non-stick, making them easy to work with, but they may not have sharp edges for precise cuts.

Size and Shape

Pie crust cookie cutters come in various sizes and shapes, so it’s essential to choose one that best fits your needs. If you’re planning on making mini pies or tarts, opt for smaller-sized cutters. On the other hand, if you want to make larger pies or decorate cakes with intricate designs, go for bigger-sized cutters. As for shapes, you can find anything from traditional round shapes to fun novelty shapes like animals or holiday-themed designs.

Handle Design

The handle design of a pie crust cookie cutter can greatly affect its usability and comfort level. Some cutters come with handles that require more hand strength to press down on the dough while others have ergonomic handles that make cutting easier and more comfortable. Consider how much pressure you’re willing to exert when choosing a handle design.

Dishwasher Safe

Cleaning up after baking can be a tedious task, so it’s always helpful to find tools that are dishwasher safe. Some pie crust cookie cutters are dishwasher safe while others need to be washed by hand. If you don’t want any extra cleaning duties after baking your delicious pies, opt for a dishwasher-safe cutter.

Price

Pie crust cookie cutters vary in price depending on their material, size, shape, and other features mentioned above. Before making your purchase decision, set a budget that works for you and keep an eye out for sales or discounts that may help you save some money.

Brand Reputation

Lastly, consider the brand reputation when purchasing a pie crust cookie cutter as it will give you an idea of its quality and durability. Do some research on different brands before making your purchase or ask friends or family who have experience using these tools.

With this buying guide in mind, I hope you’ll find the perfect pie crust cookie cutter that makes your baking experience even more enjoyable! Happy baking!

Author Profile

Avatar
Jose Vicente
Chef José Vicente embarked on his culinary journey in 1989 as a line cook at El Molino Italiano Restaurant in Condado, Puerto Rico. Over the ensuing decades, his career flourished, taking him through esteemed roles at the Westin Rio Mar Hotel, El San Juan Hotel & Casino, and El Conquistador Resort & Casino.

Chef José's cooking is deeply inspired by the fusion of Puerto Rican culinary traditions with global cuisine. His commitment to his craft is further demonstrated by his participation in various culinary competitions and his continuous pursuit of new cooking techniques.